As a Christian, I am the first person to want to help someone in need. I fully embrace charity and sacrifice as part of my mission of embracing Christ in others. My first inclination with the immigration debate that is going on was to say that it was not charitable or hospitable to deny people entry and a good life in our country, especially because our country really has no national ethnicity. This is not to say we do not have original ethnic groups, American Indians, but this is different because our society, culture, and government are not original to these groups. However, as I began to think about the issue of immigration and the other issues surrounding it, namely amnesty for illegal aliens, I felt that my charity was misplaced.
For a variety of socio-economic reasons we have illegal aliens in our country in probably almost every larger community in our country. Laborers are hired from Mexico to fill many jobs in farming, construction, landscaping, housekeeping, and other jobs in related fields. These people are often prospected by American employers looking for cheep labor. A portion of illegal aliens in our country make the entry into the country by themselves. None of this is unfamiliar to us, but these are the facts.
When you consider that most illegal aliens are regular people who come to our country to work and make a life for themselves, you feel a sense charity to help them because Americans want everyone who works to succeed. This is one of our few common values, a strong work ethic. Nearly everyone in our country is here in our country today because of this value. However, speaking of values, there are other values that Americans also embrace, values that define freedom, justice, fairness, and individualism. Justice or fairness is really the value that freedom rests upon. Equal opportunity gives the individual the power to accomplish what he or she wants. However, in order to provide equal opportunity fairly or equally, we have to have laws and due process.
Legal immigration is not an easy process, and in fact, it costs a lot of money. This would be the barrier to immigrating to our country, aside from the bureaucracy of legal entry. However, thousands of people legally immigrate to our country every year. They go through the process of legal immigration because they respect our country and our laws. Respect for our laws should be the first consideration by prospective immigrants and other parties of interest when seeking entry to the U. S. I was quite perplexed by the fact that many employers in various professions break the law to bring aliens into our country. The fact of the matter is that when employers do hire illegal aliens for jobs they pay these people much less than a U. S. citizen would make doing the very same job. This has the effect of “cheapening” our labor and actually making the job market and the economy worse. This hurts U. S. employers who are playing by the rules. The other side of the cost issue is that by immigrating illegally many folks have no choice but to use our public services, such as schools, medical care, and a variety of public assistance programs. This unexpected use on our system is an unexpected strain on these vital services, services we pay for.
I began this article saying that our charity as Christians is misplaced when we want to provide amnesty to illegal aliens. This is because we have other options to prevent people from entering our country illegally in the first place. We have the ability to make legal immigration easier, but still economically and socially responsible. We can provide a grant or scholarship to qualified individuals to enter our country to assist those with low income. We can also be more charitable to those groups of people in other countries who are coming to our country to find work. We have the ability to responsibly channel resources and education so that people, who might otherwise look to migrant work, are able to work in their own communities. We must consider that there are also adverse effects on these communities in other countries for allowing one of their most valuable assets, their people, an easy opportunity to leave.
The other pressing concern that should concern everyone in our country is that if it is so easy for an estimated 12 million illegal alien to enter our country, it is extremely easy for other groups, such as terrorists, to enter our communities as well. In our post 9/11 age, security of our country has a new priority and it means that we have to screen those entering and leaving our country much closer. This is simply a fact of life and cannot be avoided. We have a duty to follow the laws that we have set to ensure the safety of all Americans.
The challenge that we face is what to do with the illegal aliens that we already have in our country? While deportation seems logical, we must consider at what cost, how fair, and how practical it would be to begin deportations of the illegal immigrant populations. The first actions that should be taken nationwide are stiff penalties and accountability for U. S. employers. We have to make it a grave harm to their business to hire an illegal alien such that they will put in place effective programs to screen their workers and take responsibility for an issue that they helped create. Every business is replaceable by one that will comply with the law. It is much better for the consumer to pay higher prices for work performed by legal labor than pay an increased tax rate to fix illegal labor problems. Employers who use have utilized illegal labor should have to pay a penalty for engaging in illegal behavior.
To use some common sense, it does not seem practical to deport millions of people. However, to be fair, there should be a system to register these people, provide them with education on what procedures need to be followed to stay in the country, and assess what penalty they should pay to be able to stay. These folks are here illegally and there should be a punishment that fits the crime. I think it should be considered that illegal aliens who are naturalized into the country should pay a higher income tax rate for a specified period of time. I also think there should be an additional one time fine. They should also be listed on a public watch list for national security purposes as they were not legally screened for entry into the country. These folks should also be required at their cost to pay for any compliance to national heath standards that are necessary, i.e. vaccinations. There should be a deadline that these folks have to meet to get all of these things done. If these folks decide they do not want to pay a higher tax rate, a one time fine, and compliance with any other applicable laws on their own, they should be granted without penalty a grace period in which they would be able to return to their country. This proposed solution is both fair to the immigrants who are here illegally, U. S. citizens, and those who have immigrated legally.
By giving illegal aliens an option to make good with the law we are giving them opportunity. This opportunity is much better than simply granting them amnesty. The other side of this situation is that if they are in violation of immigration law they can be deported. The laws are in place for many good and valid reasons including national security, economic, public health, and equal opportunity. By granting amnesty to any illegal alien we cheapen the work that legal immigrants put into becoming citizens of our country. I believe in fairness and equal opportunity, but equal opportunity has to go both ways.
No comments:
Post a Comment